Tuesday, June 2, 2009

Dr. E. Fuller Torrey--3

How does it feel to have schizophrenia?

“Surviving Schizophrenia,” first published in 1983 and now in 5th revision, is the bible for families who have lived with someone with that particular mental illness. It defines what schizophrenia is and is not, how it is treated, what causes it, what are the courses and outcomes, what comes after, it handles questions from consumers and families, and advises on how to be an advocate. I thought it's worth rehearsing what this wonderful book has to offer, whether you're directly involved or a casual reader.
First, the book is written in a style that's clear and easy to understand without condescending to the lay reader. I find it has the best explanation of how you would tell someone what schizophrenia does to you, what it must feel like. You might be a high school kid feeling your brain is suddenly crashing in on you, or you're a parent or sibling and want to know how you manage when your close relative is going through the gyrations of an upset mind where thinking and emotions go haywire
Families are up against these wild and stressful situations and Dr. Torrey is sympathetic to all of this. We hear of so many of their tragedies and triumphs at the relatives support group meetings inside Ellis Hospital Psychiatry on a weekly basis. Some, at least, report schizophrenia in their family, while there are more reports of bipolar disorder today and a lot of cases of teenage depression and among young mothers and some old folks. Each of these illnesses come and go, flare up and die down, or stick around, so you may need to know about public mental health services here, how to obtain maintenance medicines, come in for counseling or entitlement programs, among other things. Torrey goes through those, too.
Look--when a disease like schizophrenia first strikes it's terribly distressing because no one knows what to do. There are weeks and months of waiting to see if symptoms are confirmed, to see if medicines work, to find if the individual can get back on his feet and recapture his life. Young people who are resilient enough usually can go back to their jobs, drive a car and look after family responsibilities. But some will be hit harder. Every semester, it seems, a young man or woman drops out of a local college and is hospitalized. Will he or she go back to school? Some do.
Torrey's book is particularly helpful to young people, first time sufferers.
Some of us have gone in as a team to the high schools in this area to talk to students in health classes and read passages from Surviving Schizophrenia. The idea is to tell them these diseases strike young people their age or a little older, it's a no-fault brain disease, and you can get help. You should tell your parents and school counselor if you're feeling the symptoms. There is medical treatment in the community.
How must it feel? Torrey explains that it can have devastating consequences:
In an early chapter, he writes: “Sympathy for those afflicted with schizophrenia is sparse because it is difficult to put oneself in the place of the sufferer. The whole disease process is mysterious, foreign, and frightening to most people. It is not like a flood,where one can imagine all one's possessions being washed away. Nor like a cancer, where one can imagine a slowly growing tumor, relentlessly spreading from organ to organ and squeezing life from the body. No. Schizophrenia is madness. Those who are afflicted act bizarrely, say strange things, withdraw from us, and may even try to hurt us. They are no longer the same person—they are mad!”
“Those of us who have not had this disease should ask ourselves, for example, how we would feel if our brain began playing tricks on us, if unseen voices shouted at us, if we lost the capacity to feel emotions, and if we lost the ability to reason logically. This would certainly be burden enough for any human being to have to bear. But what if, in addition to this, those closest to us began to avoid us or ignore us, to pretend that they didn't hear our comments, to pretend that they didn't notice what we did? How would we feel if those we most cared about were embarrassed by our behavior each day?” Torrey asks.
We tell the kids they shouldn't make fun of others they see acting odd in class because it's not the individual's fault. We say treatment works most of the time for most people.
Torrey goes on to explain the symptoms of schizophrenia, citing the hallmarks of hallucinations and delusions and the difficulty sufferers face in interpreting and responding to auditory and visual stimuli. Someone may have difficulty concentrating on schoolwork or even watching TV. He or she may withdraw from friends, sports and school activities and change their personality.
In regard to treatment and the impact of the illness on society, Torrey picks a fight with many of his colleagues. He argues that schizophrenia has to be treated with medicine, not talk therapy, and those unable to be treated successfully must be put aside from society (hospitalized or segregated). Those opposed to this view, he believes, are creating the dangerous situations that lead to innocent people being harmed or killed, including the sufferers themselves.
Torrey takes a whack in his book at the lack of involuntary treatment laws that would take the most vulnerable patients off the streets, those at risk of hurting themselves or others. Stubborn laws prevent these sufferers from obtaining the treatment they need, he writes. (NYS has Kendra's Law, a model for the states and a brainchild of Fuller Torrey's.)
He is ever alert to the realities of mental health services in poor communities and among minorities. He is appalled at the tragedies of the homeless and untreated mentally ill who show up in emergency rooms and jails and prisons. We are urged to act more aggressively in our advocacy to get better mental health housing, treatment and support services for this population.
And he recognizes how powerful the stigma against mental illness is for families and individual sufferers. He's devoted to erasing that.
(For more information about NAMI locally and at state and national levels, call our phone number listed on the website. And be well.) (Roy Neville)

2 comments: